Showing posts with label Marie. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Marie. Show all posts

Tuesday, September 24, 2024

2-15. Love Story/Love Song.

Jeanne creates a secret admirer to woo Lana away from Seifriet.
Jeanne creates a secret admirer to woo Lana away from Seifriet.

Super Dimension Cavalry Southern Cross: Love Story.

Original Air Date - Super Dimension Cavalry Southern Cross: July 29, 1984. Writer: Tadashi Terada. Director: Noriyasu Kogawa.

Robotech: Love Song.

Original Air Date - Robotech: May 14, 1985.
Story Editor: Steve Kramer. Supervising Director: Robert V. Barron.


PLOT - SOUTHERN CROSS

Supreme Commander Claude Leon has put Gen. Emerson in command of the newly secured Aluce Base - in a single command exiling his archrival to Gloire's moon and putting him at the front line of the war. Leon also assigns all of the officers loyal to Emerson, leaving Gloire staffed entirely with his own followers.

Jeanne has more important things on her mind - namely, romance. Sekishima, a captain assigned to the mission, approaches her to help him talk to Lana before he departs. Jeanne throws herself into this, crafting a plan for him to woo Lana as a secret admirer known as "The Rose of Gloire" - with the benefit to her that, if they succeed, she will be left with no rival for Seifriet's affections. There's only one problem: Lana is convinced that the messages are coming from Seifriet, which makes her extremely uncomfortable.

Meanwhile, Marie prepares for a special night with Charles. But when a woman from Charles's past intercepts him, their evening takes a disastrous turn...


PLOT - ROBOTECH:

Supreme Commander Anatole Leonard has put Gen. Emerson in charge of the next assault - in a single command exiling his archrival to what is likely to be a one-way mission. Leonard also assigns all of the officers loyal to Emerson, leaving Earth's headquarters staffed entirely with his own followers.

Dana has more important things on her mind - namely, romance. Komodo, a captain assigned to the mission, approaches her to help him talk to Nova before he departs. Dana throws herself into this, crafting a plan for him to woo Nova as a secret admirer - with the benefit to her that, if they succeed, she will be left with no rival for Zor's affections. There's only one problem: Nova is convinced that the messages are coming from Zor, which makes her extremely uncomfortable.

Meanwhile, Marie prepares for a special night with Sean. But when a woman from Sean's past intercepts him, their evening takes a disastrous turn...

Marie prepares for her date with Charles. Things do not go as expected.
Marie prepares for her date with Charles.
Things do not go as expected.

CHARACTERS:

Emerson knows exactly what the Supreme Commander is doing, but his sense of duty leaves him with no choice but to follow his orders. Bowie will not express his worry to Jeanne, and Emerson will not come to him. Instead, each shows their feelings silently - Bowie lost in thought as he plays the piano, Emerson stopping his car outside the barracks to listen to him play.

Charles's past promiscuity comes back to haunt him with Marie, who misinterprets his attempts to get away from an old lover. This could come across as sitcom shenanigans - but they never actually resolve the misunderstanding, with it falling to Lana and another officer to intervene on Marie's behalf. Meanwhile, the reactions of both characters show us that their attachment is deeply felt, even as the two are left in turmoil.

Advantage: None.


NARRATION:

Southern Cross's opening narration is more focused than in previous episodes, hitting all the major points that impact the plot of this installment without needless clutter. The Robotech narrator gets a bit overenthusiastic during the recap. Also, the Robotech narrator keeps coming back for scene transitions, particularly in the first half. It's far from the series' worst offender. Still, most of these intrusions are entirely unnecessary.

Advantage: Southern Cross.

Lana receives a letter from The Rose of Gloire. In Robotech, it's just from a secret admirer.
Lana receives a letter from "The Rose of Gloire."
In Robotech, it's just from a secret admirer.

CUTS AND ALTERATION:

Manually Processing the Security Checks: An early scene sees Lana manually processing security checks for the task force bound for Aluce Base. In Southern Cross, she and her superior discuss how unusual this is, as normally they would set parameters for the computer to screen. The superior officer is entirely friendly and good-natured. This is not the case in Robotech, which transforms him into a sneering jerk, making it seem all the more bizarre when he's pleasant to her later.

Angelo Is More Talkative than Andrzej: Chalk this one up to Robotech's fear of silence. When Seifriet goes to GMP Headquarters to deliver a book from Aluce Base to Lana, Southern Cross's Andrzej follows him and makes sure that he's seen - but he does not actually speak until Seifriet arrives. In Robotech, Angelo also follows Zor - only this time, he calls out things like, "Hey buddy!" and "I'm watching out for you!" every time he's on screen.

The Secret Admirer: The letters to Lana are from "the Rose of Gloire," with close-ups of that title written in English. But those letters are addressed to "Lana" and not "Nova," and Robotech occurs on Earth and not the colony of Gloire. As a result, the shots in question are removed, and "the Rose of Gloire" becomes a more generic "secret admirer."

The Roman Aspect of the Supreme Commander's Assignment: This is a change I actually like. In both versions, Lt. Brown, who is removed from the mission due to a mistake by Lana/Nova, tells her that he's glad of the error because it will let him keep an eye on the Supreme Commander. He then talks about how all dissenting voices have been methodically assigned to this mission. In Robotech, he compares this to the behavior of Roman emperors, who would "promote" dissenters to become governors of distant provinces to get rid of them, which adds a nice extra layer to the scene.

Marie Waits: While waiting for Charles, Southern Cross's Marie muses that if he takes too much longer, she'll already be drunk by the time he arrives. Robotech de-emphasizes the alcohol by changing her thoughts to impatient worries that Sean might stand her up and leave her with nothing but "cab fare."

"The Triumveroid": There's a single cutaway to the aliens as they test their new secret weapon. Robotech names it "The Triumveroid," with the scientists exulting at how it performs all essential functions of combat. The Robotech scene works just a little bit better than the Southern Cross version, in my opinion, with the description of the new weapon blending effectively with the visuals of the test.

Marie's Departure: When Marie leaves in Southern Cross, Andrzej observes that she specifically asked to join Gen. Emerson in his assignment. Robotech removes this, with Angelo just telling Sean that she has more important things to worry about than him.

Advantage: None.


INCIDENTAL MUSIC:

The only notable musical moment is Bowie playing on the piano as his father (or, in Robotech, godfather) prepares to leave on a dangerous mission, and that scene is equally effective in both versions. There is a nice use of musical continuity in Robotech, as a piano version of Minmei's It's Me is heard in the background while Marie waits for Sean, but overall both episodes use their scores about equally well.

Advantage: None.

Jeanne watches Lana and misinterprets a serious conversation.
Jeanne watches Lana and misinterprets a serious conversation.

OVERALL ADVANTAGE - NONE:

The episode is equally enjoyable in either version. The changes are relatively minor ones that have no significant impact, leaving a viewing experience that's roughly the same whether you're watching Southern Cross or Robotech.


OTHER MUSINGS:

I had low expectations given this episode's title. The "love story" aspects of Southern Cross have not impressed me. I fully believe in the Marie/Charles romance, but I have yet to be given much reason to care about it. I also have utterly failed to be convinced by the Jeanne/Seifriet relationship. Expecting that to be the focus, I braced myself for an installment that would... well, probably be bad.

Imagine my surprise when this ended up being one of the series' better episodes!

There are some amusing animations to go along with the lighthearted nature of Jeanne's secret admirer plan. When lovesick Sekishima approaches Lana, he does so with the posture of a man who badly needs to go to the bathroom. The script is also well-written, adeptly balancing a humorous "A" plot against the drama of the Supreme Commander's plan and the likely fates of those assigned to accompany Gen. Emerson. The moments of Bowie silently playing the piano express his emotions more effectively than any speech would. Even the one cutaway to the aliens, as they test their new weapon, underscores the likely fates of Emerson and his team.

Love Story ends up working all around: as a character piece, as a building block for the larger story, and as an entertaining episode in its own right - and in this case, the Robotech version works just as well as the original!


Overall Rating: 8/10.

Previous Episode: Iron Lady/Clone Chamber
Next Episode: Hunter Killer/The Hunters

Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On BlueSky:

On Threads:

Tuesday, September 17, 2024

2-14. Iron Lady/Clone Chamber.

An emotional Musica refuses an arranged marriage.
An emotional Musica refuses an arranged marriage.

Super Dimension Cavalry Southern Cross: Iron Lady.

Original Air Date - Super Dimension Cavalry Southern Cross: July 22, 1984. Writer: Tadashi Terada. Director: Yoshihito Hata.

Robotech: Clone Chamber.

Original Air Date - Robotech: May 13, 1985.
Story Editor: Steve Kramer. Supervising Director: Robert V. Barron.


PLOT - SOUTHERN CROSS

Supreme Commander Claude Leon's reckless assault has failed, with the survivors retreating to Aluce Base to regroup. Undeterred, Leon orders a new operation to reinforce the moon base, transforming it into a military outpost for future attacks. The plan is to move quickly and stealthily, so that there will be no chance for the Zor to realize what's happening. You know, unless someone who really should know better decides to start freely sharing classified information.

So on a date with Seifriet, the usually strait-laced Lana decides to talk about the operation in public with a man who, until recently, was acting as a Zor bioroid pilot. Fortunately, a jealous Jeanne interrupts before she can reveal every detail. Still, Seifriet reports enough for the Zor to locate and attack the human ships, leaving Marie rushing to save them with the already battered remnants of her squad.

All is not well among the Zor either. Seifriet's returning memories and the accompanying emotions keep interfering with his efficiency as a spy. At the same time, Musica's feelings toward Bowie cause her to refuse an arranged mating. This spurs the Zor leaders to authorize a new weapon from their scientists, in hopes of ending the war quickly and recovering their old home planet!


PLOT - ROBOTECH:

Supreme Commander Anatole Leonard's reckless assault has failed, with the survivors retreating to Moonbase Luna to regroup. Leonard orders a new operation to reinforce the moon base, transforming it into a military outpost for future attacks. The plan is to move quickly and stealthily, so that there will be no chance for the Robotech Masters to realize what's happening. You know, unless someone who really should know better decides to start freely sharing classified information.

So on a date with Zor, the usually strait-laced Nova decides to talk about the operation in public with a man who, until recently, was acting as an enemy bioroid pilot. Fortunately, a jealous Dana interrupts before she can reveal every detail. Still, Zor reports enough to allow the Masters to locate and attack the human ships, leaving Marie rushing to save them with the already battered remnants of her squad.

All is not well among the Masters either. Zor's emotions keep interfering with his efficiency as a spy. At the same time, Musica's feelings toward Bowie cause her to refuse an arranged mating. This spurs the Masters' leading Triumverate to authorize a new weapon from their scientists, one that will not only be effective against the humans, but also against the imminent invasion of the Invid!

Andrzej has a little too good a time on his enforced date with Jeanne.
Andrzej has a little too good a time
on his enforced "date" with Jeanne.

CHARACTERS:

I hope the writers aren't planning to focus on a love triangle between Jeanne, Lana, and Seifriet - not least because these scenes are by far the most annoying parts of this episode. Jeanne at least gets one fun moment around the midpoint. After Seifriet stands her up, she petulantly orders Andrzej to accompany her to the movie she had bought tickets for. Andrzej ends up having a fantastic time while she doesn't, his raucous laughter irritating her.

That's more than can be said for Lana, who up until now has been characterized as responsible and duty-driven. This episode transforms her into a complete idiot, sharing classified intelligence with Seifriet for seemingly no reason other than to flirt. Never mind Seifriet being a security risk, she's discussing this information in a public restaurant! By all rights, that should earn her a swift court martial.

By contrast, the relationship between Marie and Charles is fairly well played here. I can't claim to be any more invested than I was last episode; but when Marie and Charles are reunited at the end, I believe their reactions in a way that I just don't in the scenes involving Jeanne, Lana, and Seifriet.

Advantage: None.


NARRATION:

Both versions open with narration that recaps the previous episode, including the flowers Jeanne and Seifriet discovered in the cave. This is a surprising detail to include, given that the flowers aren't relevant to this episode. The Southern Cross recap plays like a rushed addition overall.

Robotech's narrator also mentions the flowers in the recap, but this narration provides context to connect them to the episode. We're specifically told that the Robotech Masters know of the flower thanks to their connection with Zor, and that it makes their task more urgent because it's a sign that the Invid are soon to invade. This discovery helps push them to action, making it a motivator for their scenes.

Advantage: Robotech.

Marie and Charles reunite. Robotech adds dialogue and ruins a good scene.
Marie and Charles reunite. Robotech adds
dialogue and ruins a good scene.

CUTS AND ALTERATION:

Jeanne Suggest Seifriet Not Force His Memories: When Jeanne asks Seifriet to the movie, he's fretting about his memory. She suggests that trying to force his memories back will just make them slip further away. In Robotech, the scene is shortened so that there's no productive discussion, just Dana asking Zor out.

Jeanne's Happy Dance: After Seifriet indicates that he will accompany Jeanne, she celebrates for a few seconds with a rather cute happy dance. Robotech cut the scene to the bare minimum, and the dance is one of the casualties... though it bizarrely gets put in as a flashback during the later conversation between Zor and Nova.

The Zor Energy Problem Becomes a Protoculture Problem: Southern Cross devotes some focus to a problem with low energy in the newest generation of clones, which heralds problems for the survival of the Zor. Robotech makes this part of the "protoculture shortage" that's been affecting the Masters from their very first appearance.

The Masters Approve an "Invid Fighter": The Zor leaders approve their scientists' suggestion of a more reliable fighter. Robotech keeps the basic idea of creating a unit more completely controlled by the Triumverate - but they develop it mainly to deal with the next threat, the Invid. I think this is a change for the better. The Zor/Masters are clearly winning the war against the humans. Worries about the obviously more formidable Invid give the Masters a stronger motivation to resort to an experimental solution.

Marie's Tears: When Charles comes to meet Marie at the end of Southern Cross, she begins crying as he reassures her. Southern Cross understands that Marie weeping silently is more effective than anything she might say... while Robotech blunts the emotion by having Marie tell Sean that she wasn't sure if he cared. In the first case, she's weeping for everything that's happened since she took off, from the devastating losses, to the fear of the death, to guilt at having survived when so many of her comrades died. With that one added line, Robotech reduces it to Marie focusing on the attentions of her sort-of boyfriend.

Advantage: Southern Cross. Mainly because of that last change, which sabotages a strong emotional moment.


INCIDENTAL MUSIC:

The Robotech theme kicks in when Marie rescues the relief force from the Masters' surprise attack. This just about fits the context... but apparently the theme doesn't quite match the length of the scene, so there's an extremely noticeable moment when part of the theme repeats itself.

The Southern Cross music is unexceptional, and its recycled tracks are growing about as wearisome as Robotech's by this point. But Southern Cross has the confidence to go silent during parts of the battle, while Robotech covers every second with music.

Advantage: Southern Cross.

Lana shares classified information with Seifriet. Because in this episode, Lana's an idiot.
Lana shares classified information with Seifriet.
Because in this episode, Lana's an idiot.

OVERALL ADVANTAGE - SOUTHERN CROSS:

This one was on track to being a case of "no advantage." Then Robotech added that one line for its Marie/Sean scene, wrecking one of Southern Cross's best emotional moments. If you take that away, the two versions are very close in both content and quality, with a few changes that even favor Robotech. But that late scene is enough to tip the scales toward the original version.


OTHER MUSINGS:

Iron Lady pushes the plot forward in potentially interesting ways, and it benefits from another pretty good action scene. It also offers one of the better comedic moments, with the art and animation of Andrzej howling in the movie theater as Jeanne scowls making for a genuinely funny moment.

I am really missing the way the Zor were portrayed in the early episodes: Not speaking, just reacting to each other's unheard telepathic communications. Now they're just as chatty in Southern Cross as in Robotech, and they are far less intriguing as a result. I'll allow that this makes it easier for the writers to have the aliens explain their motivations to each other, but I think a lot of atmosphere is lost as a result.

The episode is enjoyable enough. But while it moves the story forward, I can't make myself think it's particularly good. The strained love triangle and particularly the out-of-character behavior of Lana really soured me on this installment.


Overall Rating: 5/10.

Previous Episode: Triple Mirror/Triumvirate
Next Episode: Love Story/Love Song

Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On BlueSky:

On Threads:

Tuesday, September 10, 2024

2-13. Triple Mirror/Triumvirate.

Jeanne's triple mirror stirs up Seifriet's memories.
Jeanne's triple mirror stirs up Seifriet's memories.

Super Dimension Cavalry Southern Cross: Triple Mirror.

Original Air Date - Super Dimension Cavalry Southern Cross: July 15, 1984. Writer: Jinzô Toriumi. Director: Yuusaku Satsukime.

Robotech: Triumvirate.

Original Air Date - Robotech: May 10, 1985.
Story Editor: Steve Kramer. Supervising Director: Robert V. Barron.


PLOT - SOUTHERN CROSS

Supreme Commander Claude Leon orders an attack on the Zor fleet. This time, he insists they will succeed because now their Auroran attack chopper is ready to deploy. Marie is assigned to lead the Aurorans, while the Zor watch the humans lift off in disbelief that their enemy could be quite this stupid.

As the Zor engage in easy target practice, inspiration strikes Jeanne about how to recover Seifriet's memories. She takes him to the three mounds, the place where she and Bowie first encountered him. Searching the area, they find a cavern - and deeper inside, they uncover a secret that might just be the key to understanding the Zor!


PLOT - ROBOTECH:

Supreme Commander Anatole Leonard orders an attack on the Robotech Masters. This time, he insists they will succeed because now their AJAX attack chopper is ready to deploy. Marie is assigned to lead the AJAX units. The Masters watch the humans lift off in disbelief that their enemy could be quite this stupid.

As the Robotech Masters engage in easy target practice, inspiration strikes Dana for recovering Zor's memories. She takes him to the three mounds, the site of the battle that destroyed the SDF-1. Searching the area, they find a cavern - and deeper inside, they uncover a secret that leaves Zor in a state of terror!

Claude Leon decides that a frontal assault against a
superior force is a good idea. Because he's an imbecile.
Claude Leon decides that a frontal assault against a
superior force is a good idea. Because he's an imbecile.

CHARACTERS:

Jeanne is harboring a planet-sized crush on Seifriet. I continue to wish that some of her anger from Déjà Vu lingered, as that was a character beat that was both convincing and interesting. At this point, though, I increasingly doubt the series will follow up on it.

Jeanne impulsiveness continues to be an effective approach with Seifriet. The instant she thinks of taking him to the mounds, she calls up Bowie and simply does it. She later acknowledges defying orders, earning a sigh from Lana. It's clear that Jeanne's philosophy more or less follows the old saying that it's easier to ask for forgiveness than permission.

Charles continues to romantically pursue Marie, and she's thawing in her attitude toward him. I wish I could care, but neither character has received enough attention or been granted enough depth for me to feel at all invested. Oh, and at this point, Claude Leon (and his Robotech counterpart, Anatole) is just an imbecile. One who seems determined to wipe out his own forces a mere three episodes after being told that he'll receive no reinforcements. At this point, Gen. Emerson would save a lot of Gloirian lives, and greatly increase the odds of a successful resolution to the conflict, if he were willing to arrange an "accident" for his superior.

Advantage: None.


NARRATION:

The Robotech episode is restrained in its narration... with one exception. At the midpoint, when Dana decides to take Zor to the ruins of the SDF-1 to jog his memory, the narrator has to tell us why she's doing this. Never mind that she's just said why she's doing it, and never mind that she restates it a minute or so later. I have no idea why the writers felt compelled to add that bit of narration, but it's enough to tip the advantage to the original version.

Advantage: Southern Cross.

A cavern full of flowers. Southern Cross's Seifriet reacts quite differently than Robotech's Zor.
A cavern full of flowers. Southern Cross's Seifriet
reacts quite differently than Robotech's Zor.

CUTS AND ALTERATION:

The Supreme Commander's Speech: The episode begins with Supreme Commander Leon making a speech about the upcoming attack. In Southern Cross, he full-throatedly stirs up the troops by promising that they will "crush the Zor." In Robotech, Anatole Leonard is more realistic, talking about the dangers of the upcoming battle.

Nova Has Been Assigned to Zor's Rehabilitation: In Southern Cross, Lana tries to persuade Jeanne that she should be part of the effort to recover Seifriet's memories. Robotech changes the scene so that Nova has been assigned to Zor, with her telling Dana: "It's out of your hands."

Subterranean Flowers: Seifriet, Jeanne, and Bowie find strange flowers in a cavern, which Seifriet knows are in some way important. All of this is the same in both versions. In Southern Cross, no sense of malevolence is attached to this discovery. Robotech has a third arc to set up, though, so Zor talks about the flowers as if they are dangerous, saying that he can sense them calling out to something far away. 

The Supreme Commander's Aide: At the end of the episode, the Supreme Commander's aide reports the results of the attack. In Southern Cross, he's as pig-headed as Claude Leon, scoffing at how pathetically their troops performed. In maybe the only distinct improvement in Robotech, the aide reports the losses and retreat as a normal person would, and he reacts with appropriate surprise when Anatole declares that they'll follow up with yet another frontal assault.

A Telling Final Shot: Not significant, but worth noting. The final shot of Southern Cross has the camera tilting up to show Gloire's two moons. But since Robotech is set on Earth, the shot is cut short - but not so short that the camera doesn't visibly begin moving upward just before the cutaway.

Advantage: Southern Cross.


INCIDENTAL MUSIC:

I have a basically split verdict on the music in this episode. The first part of the Robotech episode has some odd cues, notably when "adrenaline pumping" music is used right after Dana's conversation with Nova - and then cut short a few seconds later. I also think the Southern Cross music is more generally effective in the pre-battle part of the episode and in the cavern scenes. However, as usual, the Robotech tracks give a substantial lift to the battle scenes, which are a big part of this episode.

Ultimately, I think it works out to being another case of "No Advantage."

Advantage: None.

Jeanne, Seifriet, and Bowie reach the three mounds. In Robotech, these are also the ruins of the SDF-1.
Jeanne, Seifriet, and Bowie reach the three mounds.
In Robotech, these are also the ruins of the SDF-1.

OVERALL ADVANTAGE - NONE:

In this case, the two versions are very close together. Most of the changes are minor, save for those specifically made for the sake of Robotech's continuity. It's basically the same episode, and each variant is about as good as the other.


OTHER MUSINGS:

This was a definite improvement over the previous installment. The story moves along nicely, cutting back and forth between the threads of Marie and the space battle and Jeanne and Seifriet investigating the mounds. It's well paced, and the plot pays off elements from the last episode - notably Claude Leon's rash decision to attack and the entire thread about Seifriet's lost memory.

There are several arresting images: the triple reflection of Jeanne in her mirror, which prompts Seifriet's memory that "the Zor are Trinities"; the tiny figures of our trinity of Jeanne, Seifriet, and Bowie standing before the trinity of the three mounds; the cavern with the flowers; and a number of individual images during the space battle. I could nitpick about recycled shots... but honestly, what show of this era didn't do that? This is a good-looking episode.

I wasn't as invested in the space battle as I'd have liked. First, it's not like there was any question of the attack working. It's been a whopping three episodes since the Zor devastated the human relief forces. The Supreme Commander's all-out assault just serves to make him look even more incompetent than he did already. Nor is there any suspense about Marie's fate; unlike Macross, the regulars in this series have absolute Plot Armor. Between these issues, I found myself just sitting back to watch the 'splosions, and wait for the inevitable result.

The Jeanne/Seifriet material is more interesting. I enjoyed the cavern exploration, and I look forward to seeing where that is going. I remain annoyed at how readily the squad has accepted Seifriet, which feels emotionally false to me, but at least it's an interesting thread.

Overall, this is a good episode that's effective in advancing the main arc and leaving me interested to see what happens next.


Overall Rating: 7/10.

Previous Episode: Lost Memory/A New Recruit
Next Episode: Iron Lady/Clone Chamber

Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On BlueSky:

On Threads:

Tuesday, August 27, 2024

2-11. Déjà Vu.

Jeanne comes face-to-face with Seifriet, the enemy pilot who's caused her so much trouble.
Jeanne comes face-to-face with Seifriet, the
enemy pilot who's caused her so much trouble.

Original Air Date - Super Dimension Cavalry Southern Cross: July 1, 1984. Writer: Jinzô Toriumi. Director: Yasuo Hasegawa.

Original Air Date - Robotech: May 8, 1985.
Story Editor: Steve Kramer. Supervising Director: Robert V. Barron.


PLOT - SOUTHERN CROSS

Gen. Emerson orders that Seifriet, the captured Bioroid pilot, be moved to a military hospital and placed under Lana's direct supervision. As she questions Seifriet, he is able to remember that he was a second lieutenant on Aluce Base when the Zor attacked - but he can't recall anything that happened in between the attack and being found by Lana.

Charles notices the tight security in the hospital when he visits Marie. He finds out that "the red Bioroid" is being kept on the top floor and informs the squad. Jeanne declares that she has to see this prisoner with her own eyes - and for a change, Andrzej is in firm agreement in wanting answers from him.

They hatch a plan to infiltrate the hospital. But when Jeanne comes face to face with Seifriet, the prisoner is able to remember one thing - leading to a particularly upsetting revelation...


PLOT - ROBOTECH:

Gen. Emerson orders that the captured Bioroid pilot be moved to a military hospital and placed under Nova's direct supervision. When she questions the prisoner, he is unable to remember anything beyond vague impressions of being in a battle. He tries to remember more, but the pain is too intense for him to bear.

Visiting Marie in the hospital, Sean finds out that the captured pilot is being kept on the top floor. Dana declares that she has to see this prisoner and get some answers from him. Angelo disagrees with her, as usual, but he goes along with her plan anyway.

They infiltrate the hospital easily enough. But when Dana comes face to face with her former enemy, she is surprised by just how human he seems...

Lana tries to help Seifriet regain his memory.
Lana tries to help Seifriet regain his memory.

CHARACTERS:

Jeanne is increasingly tormented by nightmares. She feels guilty about Marie's injury, which occurred in the same battle as George's death. When she confronts Seifriet, all her guilt consolidates into a single source: the deaths of people under her command. Andrzej wants answers, but I think Jeanne's goal may actually be to confront and kill Seifriet. Even as Andrzej and her squad celebrate a successful operation, she remains shaken.

All of this is simplified in Robotech. There's no sense that Dana might be pursuing vigilante justice, and there's relatively little sense of any great mass of internalized guilt. As a result, her confrontation with Zor is less charged - which isn't helped by the changed context robbing the scene of its big reveal.

Advantage: Southern Cross.


NARRATION:

Southern Cross opens with a quick recap of the situation given at the very start. The opening Robotech narration covers the same general ground, but I think it's better written. And while Robotech does feature a small amount of in-episode narration, it's not intrusive. As a result, for a rare change, I'm giving this category to the American version.

Advantage: Robotech.

The Zor leaders discuss their hopes for the spy they've planted.
In Robotech, the Masters have different goals.
The Zor leaders discuss their hopes for the spy they've planted.
In Robotech, the Masters have different goals. 

CUTS AND ALTERATION:

The Reason for the Spy: The episode opens with the alien leaders talking about the spy they've planted among the humans. Southern Cross's Zor race hopes for insight into human psychology and specific intelligence that will let them defeat the humans without harming Gloire's environment. The Robotech Masters are just waiting for their Zor clone to pinpoint the location of the protoculture. Also, while Southern Cross's Seifriet is a human who was brainwashed, Robotech's Zor is not, with the Masters even remarking on how stupid the humans are to believe that he might be.

Bowie's Remarks About Musica: Both versions see Bowie talking about the girl he met on the alien ship. In Southern Cross, he says to Jeanne that he can sense that she's not a bad person, which makes him believe that there are those among the Zor who could be reasoned with. Robotech bizarrely changes this to him speculating that, because he's sure that she's not a bad person, she therefore "isn't one of them." Because apparently all of the aliens must, by definition, be evil.

The Prisoner's Recollections: Southern Cross's Seifriet specifically recalls being a soldier assigned to Aluce Base. When Lana presses him for more information, he experiences a painful, nightmarish vision. Robotech can't have this be in silence, so the Zor clone narrates the entire vision before vowing to not try to to remember if the pain will just stop. I actually like that last part of the Robotech scene, but the unnarrated Southern Cross version is otherwise the more effective one.

Andrzej Supports Jeanne's Plan; Angelo Argues Against It: When Jeanne declares that she wants to see the Bioroid pilot, Andrzej agrees that he would also like some answers. Robotech's Angelo says the exact opposite, stating that they should keep their noses out of it. I have no idea why this change was made, save that Andrzej is a three-dimensional character while Angelo is more or less "the Frank Burns" of the show.

Dana Is Much Less Angry than Jeanne: Jeanne is bristling with anger during the confrontation with Seifriet. Dana doesn't show nearly as much emotion when she confronts the Zor clone, even when she blames him for the deaths of men under her command. In Robotech, she sounds downright friendly when he remembers Musica, encouraging him to remember more. Oh, and the half-alien Dana drops the following line: "You aliens are all alike! Um... unless the writers are trying to imply some hitherto-unseen self-hatred, I'm wondering if they just plain forgot about her origins.

The Ending: Southern Cross ends with Seifriet remembering something that shakes Jeanne to her core. Robotech's changed context doesn't allow for the same revelation, which blunts the effectiveness of the ending. It also makes it a bit of a head-scratcher why Dana is so shaken at the end of the episode.

Advantage: Southern Cross.


INCIDENTAL MUSIC:

Both scores are well applied, with no moments that are noticeably more effective in either version.

Advantage: None.

Jeanne, in a rare contemplative mood, looks out on Gloire's moons.
Jeanne, in a rare contemplative mood.

OVERALL ADVANTAGE - SOUTHERN CROSS:

Robotech is hobbled by having to remove the big reveal. As a result, Southern Cross is able to hit harder. The Robotech episode is still good, but the episode's biggest punch has been taken away from it.


OTHER MUSINGS:

Déjà Vu is neatly divided into two halves. The first half is dominated by the ongoing arc: the plans of the Zor, Gen. Emerson's hopes to gain vital information from Seifriet, and Lana's attempts to help Seifriet to remember his past. These elements get more screen time in the first half than Jeanne and the 15th squadron do, though a couple of scenes do show her mounting feelings of guilt and frustration.

The second half transforms into a caper flick, with the 15th infiltrating the hospital. This is achieved a little too easily, playing out like something from a midseason A-Team episode, but it's still rather fun - though Jeanne's nurse's outfit looks less like a real nurse's uniform than like something picked out an adult specialty shop.

Just when the episode seems to be settling in as light entertainment, the confrontation between Jeanne and Seifriet sees the tone shift again. Their scene is emotional, with Jeanne left even more shaken than she's been throughout the episode. The contrast between the heavier emotional material and the lightheartedness of the big set piece is effective... though I can't say that the ending revelation was particularly hard to see coming.

As mentioned, Robotech's ending is defanged by having to remove the major revelation. Even so, relatively few changes were made to the rest of the episode, and the overall structure and the clash of tones still works - just not quite as well as in the original version.


Overall Rating - Southern Cross: 8/10.

Overall Rating - Robotech: 7/10.

Previous Episode: Outsider/The Outsiders
Next Episode: Lost Memory/A New Recruit

Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On BlueSky:

On Threads:

Tuesday, July 9, 2024

2-05. Trouble City/Danger Zone.

Jeanne sets her sights on a new dress. A major military operation ensues.
Jeanne wants a new dress. A major military operation ensues.

Super Dimension Cavalry Southern Cross - Trouble City.

Original Air Date - Super Dimension Cavalry Southern Cross: May 13, 1984. Writer: Jinzô Toriumi. Director: Susumu Nagao.

Robotech - Danger Zone

Original Air Date - Robotech: Apr. 30, 1985.
Story Editor: Steve Kramer. Supervising Director: Robert V. Barron.


PLOT - SOUTHERN CROSS

The Zor mothership continues to hover overhead. Claude Leon, the supreme general of the Southern Cross, orders an attack over Gen. Emerson's objections - an attack that results in devastating losses to the colony, with no damage done to the Zor.

This provides Jeanne with an opportunity. She wants to buy a very specific expensive dress, not least because both Marie and Lana also want it. There's one problem: Jeanne is broke. She'll need to distinguish herself to be able to draw the needed advance on her salary.

Fortunately, Louis Ducasse - one of her subordinates - is an engineering genius. Louis has a theory that the alien ship's drive system might be vulnerable to a targeted attack, provided an assault unit can get in close. The scientists agree, and with a bit of persuasion from Jeanne, Gen. Emerson allows her to lead a second, targeted attack: For the honor of her squad, for the security of Gloire, and - most importantly - for the right to buy that dress and rub Marie's and Lana's noses in it!


PLOT - ROBOTECH:

The Robotech Masters' mothership continues to hover overhead. Anatole Leonard, the supreme commander of the Army of the Southern Cross, orders an attack over Gen. Emerson's objections - an attack that results in devastating losses to the colony, with no damage done to the enemy.

Fortunately, Louis - one of Dana Sterling's subordinates - is an engineering genius. Louis has a theory that the alien ship's drive system might be vulnerable to a targeted attack, provided an assault unit can get in close. The scientists agree, and with a bit of persuasion from Dana, Gen. Emerson allows her to lead a second, targeted attack!

Claude Leon, supreme general of the Southern Cross, looks like Lex Luthor and has the personality to match.
Claude Leon, supreme general of the Southern Cross,
looks like Lex Luthor and has the personality to match.

CHARACTERS:

This episode continues the ongoing difference in characterization between Jeanne and Dana. Carefree, frivolous Jeanne is motivated to perform a heroic action so that she can buy a dress - specifically, a dress that she had rejected until Marie and Lana wanted it. By contrast, Dana acts solely out of sense of duty.

We get some focus on Louis, who has thus far been "present" but hasn't actually done much. Here, we learn that he's a bit of a tech genius... something that probably should have been introduced before this point, as it feels awfully convenient that he just happens to have this extraordinary knowledge base at the exact moment that it's needed.

Trouble City also introduces Claude Leon, Gen. Emerson's superior. He looks like Lex Luthor and has the personality to match, only minus the brains. He's written as less directly antagonistic in Robotech, though he's still the commander who forces a disastrously bad call in either version.

Advantage: None.


NARRATION:

Once the Robotech episode gets past its extended recap, the remaining narration is fairly restrained. As a result, the bulk of the voice over is restricted to the equivalent of a "Previously on..." segment.

Advantage: None

Marie and Lana make faces at the camera. Robotech removes their motivation, making an already bad moment incoherent.
Marie and Lana make faces at the camera. Robotech removes
their motivation, making an already bad moment incoherent.

CUTS AND ALTERATION:

Robotech Opens with a Recap: The Robotech episode spends almost two minutes summarizing the events of the previous episode, even though those events are only briefly mentioned here. I think this can safely be put down to padding the runtime to make up for one big cut...

Jeanne, Marie, and Lana Shop for a Dress - but Only in Southern Cross. This three-minute scene sets up Jeanne's personal quest, as she shops for and rejects a dress - only to decide that she must have it after Marie and Lana express interest in it. I agree with this cut; all of this works with Southern Cross's Jeanne, but not so much for Robotech's Dana's. My only complaint is that Robotech should have also cut the ending scene, as it's a callback to a subplot that's been otherwise removed.

Anatole Leonard Is Conciliatory to Emerson: Southern Cross's Claude Leon is scornful of Emerson. He pushes for the ill-fated offensive, then denounces its inevitable failure as pitiful before stalking out. Robotech's Anatole half-apologizes to Emerson for overruling him, stating the assault "was the only way." When it goes spectacularly wrong, he seems suitably shocked.

Scientists Confirm the Enemy Are Not Miniaturized Zentraedi: Both episodes feature a scene with scientists studying an alien bioroid. In Southern Cross, the main finding is that the fighter is controlled by a human pilot; in Robotech, the report confirms that the pilot is not a miniaturized Zentraedi. Given that "The Macross Saga" told us that the Zentraedi were genetically identical to humans, I'm not sure how they determine this. That aside, it's a good choice to use the "Macross Saga" backstory; after the Zentraedi, it would seem strange for the humans to be shocked at the existence of human-looking aliens.

A Lot More Technobabble: The Southern Cross episode establishes that the alien ship uses a particle reactor to move, and that it can be disabled by disturbing the ship's balance - and it's expressed as straightforwardly as that. The Robotech episode inserts extra Technobabble about space folding and simultaneous implosions and explosions. Given that it ends up with the same result, I'm not sure why.

Bowie's Relationship to Emerson: As the last episode revealed, Southern Cross's Emerson is Bowie's father. Robotech changes this so that Emerson is a friend of Bowie's father who agreed to look out for the young man... which basically makes their relationship the same, only less direct. Why? The most likely response is that it was the '80s and they didn't want a mixed-race father-and-son, but... Well, the show had already featured an interracial romance in "The Macross Saga," with Claudia and Roy, and that didn't stop Robotech from being a hit, so I have no clue why this was changed.

Dana Does Not Tear Her New Dress: Jeanne buys the dress, much to the annoyance of Marie and Lana. As she gets onto her bike, she catches the hem on a fire hydrant and rips it as she zips away, prompting Marie and Lana to laugh and make faces at the camera. I already find this bad, even borderline embarrassing. Robotech manages to make a terrible scene even worse by making only one change: unlike Jeanne, Dana doesn't tear her dress. As a result, there's no reason for Marie and Nova's reaction. It's a lame and unfunny gag either way... but at least the Southern Cross version is coherent.

Advantage: Southern Cross.

Robotech's music makes the big action climax feel rushed.
Robotech's music makes the big action climax feel rushed.

INCIDENTAL MUSIC:

The big action climax provides another look at the impact of music on a scene, but this time it's not in Robotech's favor. As usual, Robotech has left the action set piece untouched. However, the music is changed to a succession of almost all of Robotech's action tracks, one after another. Rather than energizing the scene, as has been the case in some previous episodes, this time it utterly ruins it.

Southern Cross allows several moments to play with either subdued music that most viewers won't consciously register or with no music at all. Robotech, afraid of silence as always, never lets the music stop. Southern Cross brings in music to emphasize moments of tension. Robotech just lines up a series of fast-paced tracks. This destroys any emphasis on one moment over another.

Even worse, that succession of fast tempo music makes the action feel rushed. I actually went back and checked the timing of the sequence in both versions afterward. There's no real difference... but while it plays cleanly and easy-to-follow in Southern Cross, it feels like an almost senseless jumble of activity in Robotech. And the reason why is all down to the music.

Advantage: Southern Cross

Human scientists study the Zor bioroid.
Human scientists study the Zor bioroid.

OVERALL ADVANTAGE - SOUTHERN CROSS:

The Southern Cross version is better than Robotech for two main reasons: The light-hearted early scenes in town, which have been greatly reduced in Robotech, create a contrast with the more serious tone of the rest of the episode; and, more importantly, the climactic action piece works in Southern Cross and falls badly flat in Robotech.


OTHER MUSINGS:

I'll start with the good elements. The introduction of Claude Leon/Anatole Leonard will almost certainly create plot complications moving forward, and the show is at the point where it needs something more than "brave squad of misfits battles formidable aliens" to maintain interest. The episode moves quickly. It also does the best job yet of juggling the ensemble, finding good moments for not only Jeanne, but also Louis, Charles, Andrzej, and Bowie. It's generally watchable, even if it isn't good.

That aside, this episode is extremely dumb. How do Jeanne and her squadron break through the Zor defenses in the first place? These same defenses effortlessly wiped out the forces sent by Emerson and Leon, none of which came close to even scratching the paint of the alien ship! A better script might show the squad analyzing the data from the battle and discovering a gap that a small force can exploit... but no. They get through simply because, unlike the nameless pilots in the first half, they have Plot Armor!

Also, the battle is much too easy. Jeanne's squad is literally on enemy territory. This should be a grueling fight to reach the Death Star vent... er, drive system. Nope. They blast a few bioroids as they all but stroll to the Designated Weak Spot in order to Blow It Up Real Good. Given that the vulnerability has to do with throwing the ship off balance, it can be said that the Zor literally roll over and die for Jeanne and her squad.

I labeled the previous episode the best one so far in Southern Cross. Well, this one earns the opposite, less desirable title, as easily my least favorite Southern Cross episode so far - and impressively, the Robotech version is even worse!


Overall Rating - Southern Cross: 4/10.

Overall Rating - Robotech: 3/10.

Previous Episode: Half Moon
Next Episode: Prelude/Prelude to Battle

Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On BlueSky:

On Threads:

Tuesday, June 25, 2024

2-03. Star Angel/Volunteers.

A space mission proves to be more dangerous than Jeanne bargained for.
A space mission proves to be more
dangerous than Jeanne bargained for.

Super Dimension Cavalry Southern Cross: Star Angel

Original Air Date: Apr. 29, 1984. Writer: Hisato Shimogochi. Director: Fumio Tashiro.

Robotech: Volunteers

Original Air Date: Apr. 26, 1985.
Story Editor: Steve Kramer. Supervising Director: Robert V. Barron.


PLOT - SOUTHERN CROSS

The Zor ships continue to blockade Gloire. They aren't actually doing anything, but their jamming technology prevents the human colony from contacting its home world, Liberté.

Marie volunteers to lead a mission into space. Two shuttles will attempt to push past the blockade to get a message out requesting reinforcements. Jeanne volunteers to accompany her, bringing Bowie and Andrzej along for the ride.

Jeanne is excited about going into space and seems to regard the whole scenario as a personal vacation. Then an accident occurs, resulting in the destruction of the second shuttle and all aboard, leading her to realize just how perilous her current assignment really is...


PLOT - ROBOTECH:

The Robotech Masters continue to blockade Earth. So far, they're taking no action, but Command is certain that they will move soon to claim the protoculture factory.

Rather than wait to react, Marie Crystal is assigned to lead a mission into space. Two shuttles will attempt to push past the blockade to get a message out to Space Station Liberty to request reinforcements. Dana volunteers to accompany her, bringing Bowie and Angelo along for the ride.

It's a perilous mission, but Dana is certain that she's up to it. Then an accident occurs, resulting in the destruction of the second shuttle and all aboard - and leaving Dana frozen in terror...

Marie leads a mission that becomes complicated by Jeanne's behavior.
Marie leads a mission that becomes
complicated by Jeanne's behavior.

CHARACTERS:

This installment offers some noticeable differences in characterization. Southern Cross's Jeanne continues to be annoyingly carefree, volunteering herself and members of her squad simply because she wants to go into space. By contrast, Dana takes the mission completely seriously from the start - which actually causes some weirdness in the middle of the episode; a bit involving a fashion magazine fits perfectly with Jeanne's attitude, but it seems actively out of character for Dana.

Other characters are also slightly different between the two shows. Southern Cross's Marie is cold. When the other shuttle is destroyed, she calmly observes that differences in skill (between her and the other pilot) make a difference in space. Robotech's Marie Crystal is still brusque, but she reacts with shock at the other shuttle's accident, while an internal monologue has her worried about Dana's state of mind.

Finally, Robotech's Angelo seems to be deliberately trying to make Dana look bad early in the episode. He fails to tell her about the squad's mechs being transplanted to the shuttle, causing her to be late to the mission. No such sabotage is perpetrated by Andrzej in Southern Cross, with Jeanne's tardiness being 100% her own fault.

Advantage: Southern Cross.


NARRATION:

After showing restraint for most of the episode, the Robotech narrator goes into overdrive at the end. His enthusiasm for the success of "The Robotech Defenders" (TM) is such that I half-wondered if someone needed to clean up the recording booth after he finished his verbal ejaculation.

Advantage: Southern Cross

Jeanne attempts to read a fashion magazine during liftoff. It doesn't go well.
Jeanne attempts to read a fashion
magazine during liftoff. It doesn't go well.

CUTS AND ALTERATION:

Reasons for Volunteering: Jeanne volunteers solely because she wants to go into space. Only after the explosion of the other shuttle makes her realize the danger of the situation does she take anything seriously. Robotech's Dana volunteers because she believes the mission is important and that she and her people are up for it... which basically encapsulates the difference between the two characterizations in a nutshell.

Jeanne Goes Shopping, While Dana Goes to Inspect Squad Equipment: This also ties into the changed characterization. Jeanne rushes into town before the mission to buy the latest issue of her fashion magazine, realizing that she's late while on her way back to the base. Dana goes directly to inspecting the squad's hovertanks... which also allows the Robotech episode an "extra ad break" trim.

Dana Is Described as a "Tactical Genius": It's just a single line of dialogue from Gen. Emerson in Robotech, but it gave me a genuine "WTF!?!" reaction. Dana has performed well in two battles, saving the base in the second one. In the process, she has shown an ability to adjust on the fly to changing situations. This is a vital trait in a leader - but it does not represent genius, tactical or otherwise. The original exchange in Southern Cross is much better: The officers express reservations about Jeanne's inexperience and attitude, which Emerson counters by pointing out that she's been effective against the Zor so far - a statement that's undeniably accurate without overstating her abilities.

The Ill-Fated Allied Ship: In Southern Cross, the accident that befalls the other shuttle is down to pilot error. Robotech changes this into a catastrophic malfunction, something that is not the pilot's fault in any way.

Added Dialogue During the Battle: Though this is the exact type of addition that annoyed me in Macross, here it ends up being a good thing. I found the editing of the big battle scene to be haphazard, and I had trouble tracking where characters were, what their status was, and what they were trying to do. Robotech inserts lines that clarify all of these points. The movement from shot to shot still feels a bit jagged, but the added lines eliminate the confusion.

Advantage: Southern Cross. Though the improvements to the final battle almost make this one even.


INCIDENTAL MUSIC:

The pop themed music for Southern Cross works rather well during the light-hearted first half. It's in the action scenes that the soundtrack falls flat, with its "tense" music just seeming generic. Robotech's incidentals carry the tense moments better, particularly when the shuttle is flying directly underneath the alien mothership.

Robotech's use of its score stumbles at the climax, though. When Dana gets into her mech to join the battle outside the ship, the main theme starts up. The problem with this is context. This is still a tense moment. Marie and Dana are in imminent danger, and the mission actually appears to be a failure. The triumphant, stirring tones of Ulpio Minucchi's theme end up being badly at odds with the actual content.

That misjudgment leaves me favoring the original version this time. Yes, the action score is generic - but a generic score appropriately applied is preferable to a good score that is badly applied.

Advantage: Southern Cross

A terrified Jeanne freezes at a critical moment.
A terrified Jeanne freezes at a critical moment.

OVERALL ADVANTAGE - SOUTHERN CROSS:

Jeanne's arc makes this the first Southern Cross installment in which I've found her to be better-characterized than Robotech's Dana, and that's the main reason why I'm giving the advantage to Southern Cross.

The first half of the episode shows Jeanne at her most irresponsible. She volunteers herself and her squad for a dangerous mission simply to go to space, shows up late because she was buying a fashion magazine, and treats both her tardiness and the takeoff as jokes. Then the other shuttle is destroyed, and she freezes until Marie snaps her out of it, after which she finally behaves with proper seriousness. This is much-needed character development, and it's actually done pretty well.

The Robotech version obliterates that character arc. Dana takes the mission seriously from the start. This creates two problems. First, because Robotech is locked into Southern Cross's animation, some of Dana's mid-episode behavior doesn't fit the context, to the point that the writers shoehorn in a few lines about her strange behavior. Second, Dana begins the episode where Jeanne ends it, meaning that she doesn't particularly grow or change.

I also question the mission objective as presented in Robotech. In Southern Cross, it makes sense: The colonial forces need to get past the enemy to contact their home planet for reinforcements. In Robotech, it is Earth being blockaded. So the homeworld, where presumably most of the citizens and soldiers live, is contacting a space station to request reinforcements from offworld - where fewer soldiers will be. I don't know that there was any way around this, but it is a case where the change in context weakens the episode.

Marie's shuttle flies under the immense Zor ship.
Marie's shuttle flies under the immense Zor ship.

OTHER MUSINGS:

In its original form, this installment greatly enhances the characters of both Jeanne and Marie. The episode offers a tense situation in either version. I particularly enjoy an extended moment of the heroes flying under the Zor ship. On the one hand, it provides temporary safety from the enemy attacks; however, they know the entire time that the attacks will resume in force the instant they emerge.

The end battle is a bit chaotic, to the point that the inserted Robotech dialogue actually helps to make sense of it. That aside, this is an enjoyable episode, particulary the Southern Cross variant.


Overall Rating - Southern Cross: 7/10.

Overall Rating - Robotech: 6/10.

Previous Episode: Makeup/Southern Cross
Next Episode: Half Moon

Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On BlueSky:

On Threads: