Showing posts with label Louis. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Louis. Show all posts

Thursday, February 19, 2026

Robotech: The Shadow Chronicles.

Ariel shows Scott Bernard a vision of a new threat to humanity.
Ariel warns Scott Bernard about a new threat to humanity.

Original Release Date: Aug. 25, 2006. Running Time: 88 minutes. Screenplay by: Ford Riley, Frank Agrama. Story by: Thomas J. Bateman, Steve Yun, Tommy Yune. Directed by: Tommy Yune, Dong-wook Lee. Produced by: Jason Netter.


THE PLOT:

It is the final day of the Invid occupation of Earth. Even as Scott Bernard and his resistance group join the final assault against Reflex Point, the forces of the Robotech Expeditionary Force engage the enemy in orbit. Failure is not an option: If they cannot drive the Invid from the Earth, they have orders to use the new Neutron-S missiles, which will devastate the planet.

As the battle rages, Capt. Vince Grant takes his ship to locate the missing SDF-3 and Admiral Rick Hunter. He finds Rick, his ship badly damaged by a singularity that was formed from the test firing of the Neutron S missiles. This weapon, prepared in cooperation with a friendly alien species, is actually a trap meant to destroy them.

The sudden arrival of this new enemy prevents Vince from rescuing the SDF-3, but he is able to fold out to warn the fleet. He arrives to discover that the war is over: The Invid Regess abandoned Earth even as it appeared her forces were winning. She also destroyed the Neutron-S missiles as she left, rendering Vince's warning seemingly irrelevant.

But this is more a pause in the action than a victory. The Invid took most of the Earth's protoculture. Without the SDF-3, humanity will run out of the power source in a little over a year. Meanwhile, the new enemy closes in, single-minded in its goal to wipe out every trace of protoculture and any species who uses it!

Young pilot Marcus Rush angrily confronts Scott.
Young pilot Marcus Rush angrily confronts Scott.

CHARACTERS:

Much like The Sentinels, this movie mixes veterans of all the previous Robotech "generations." Rick, seen only on a viewscreen, has safely aged out of even remotely resembling Super Dimension Fortress Macross's Hikaru; Louis, Dana Sterling's tech guy from "The Masters," is now Vince's science officer and tech guy, while Skull Squadron leader Maia Sterling is Dana's younger sister; Vince and android Janice, both of whom were introduced in The Sentinels; and Scott, Ariel, and the Invid Regess from "The New Generation."

I think this film does a better job than The Sentinels in integrating the returning characters with the new characters. There's a direct connection between Scott and young pilot Marcus Rush, who was his late fiancée's brother. Marcus fills roughly the same role as The Sentinels' Jack Baker, but he's a little less bland. I quite liked Marcus's interactions with Scott; Marcus, angry about the death of his sister, brags about the Invid he's killed, and his attitude resembles Scott near the start of "The New Generation," before his feelings for Ariel made him more conflicted.

None of the characters has much depth - but then, The Shadow Chronicles never tries to be character-centric. This is an action film, and the cast is there to serve the plot and set pieces. They work well enough on that basis, though; and unlike in The Sentinels or Robotech: The Movie, all the characters actually seem to be part of the same story.

Maia Sterling, leader of Skull Squadron.
Maia Sterling, leader of Skull Squadron, and Marcus's crush.

PROBLEMS: ART STYLE AND CONTINUITY:

The opening credits create an immediate bad impression. After a few bars of Ulpio Minucci's original theme, it quickly devolves into generic "space music" that sounds as if it was taken from an off-brand Stargate knockoff, while we move past CGI planets that look drawn from a PS1 game.

There's a clash of art styles throughout the film. Character animation is a bit basic, with at least one point at which voice-over dialogue covers offscreen actions, but I was able to adjust to it quickly enough. The space scenes, however, use obvious CGI that results in an overly-polished "video game cutscene" look, and the two styles do not mesh well visually.

An even bigger problem is some poor continuity with the original series. The Shadow Chronicles overlaps significantly with the events of Symphony of Light, Robotech's series finale. In concept, this could work well. I might have enjoyed seeing the old events presented from a different viewpoint and with additional context.

However, this movie chooses to contradict Symphony of Light. Scott's team no longer negotiates with the Regess; Ariel talks to her alone. Also, Scott fully trusts Ariel, with absolutely no tension existing between them; yes, "New Generation" toned down the overt hostility of Mospeada's Stig, but the tension still existed. Here, it isn't present at all, even though showing that in Scott's early scenes would have made the parallels between Scott and Marcus stronger (or indeed extant, for those viewing the movie without having seen the series).

There's no actual reason for these contradictions. The end of "The New Generation" shows Scott jettisoning the message from his late fiancée, symbolically letting the past and his anger go, which would fit his warmer attitude toward Ariel here, and the Ariel of "The New Generation" would still warn Scott about the imminent threat. The conflicts appear to exist solely for the sake of making changes, and it doesn't help that those changes are uniformly worse and less interesting than the original scenes.

Even more bizarre is that the obvious audience would be old fans. And science fiction and anime fans are known for forgiving continuity issues in much the way that liquid magma is known for its cooling properties...

Louis helps a wounded Vince Grant.
Louis assists a wounded Vince Grant.

OTHER MUSINGS:

...And despite all these issues, along with a hefty helping of Robotech's trademark clunky dialogue, I still enjoyed The Shadow Chronicles.

It's nowhere near as good as the series. Still, of the attempts to continue the Robotech story, I would rate this one as the best. Admittedly, "best animated Robotech continuation" is a dubious title, given that the competition consists of Robotech: The Movie (a mess) and The Sentinels (enjoyable, but kind of bland). Still, for what it's worth, it gets my vote.

The Shadow Chronicles is an action movie. The first half is dominated by battle scenes, while the final twenty minutes amounts to one big set piece, with Vince and his crew using what they know about the new enemy to find a way to effectively resist. In between is a roughly 20 minute stretch with some character scenes and expositional material, but even this interval is very much structured to funnel the characters back into the plot as efficiently as possible.

As a rule, I prefer character material to "blowing stuff up real good." In this case, though, I think the action focus is a good choice. The characters have just enough spark to hold my interest for a short action story, but they would need some serious additional development to keep me interested for a weekly series of any length.

The writing has some of the same problems as The Sentinels, with relatively flat characters and dialogue that rarely rises above the level of "functional." That movie suffered from it, as the scenes surrounding the launch of the SDF-3 were... well, mostly boring. The Shadow Chronicles avoids that problem by keeping its plot moving and keeping the 'splosions coming.

It's Robotech as if made by Michael Bay: weak characters, weaker attempts at broad comedy, and villains who appear motivated by Being Evil (TM). But the set pieces keep coming, and even with the artificiality of the space-set action scenes, it's enough to keep me reasonably engaged even if my brain can't help but kick against it a bit.

The Children of the Shadow plot to destroy humanity. Because they're evil.
The Children of the Shadow plot to destroy humanity. Because they're evil.

OVERALL:

I enjoyed The Shadow Chronicles... probably more than I should have, given its many issues. Most of the problems I had with The Sentinels apply here, with extra bad continuity and character animation that clashes with that of the space battles. Still, judged as an action film, it works reasonably well. The new enemy is suitably formidable, which creates a bit of tension, and all of the characters do enough to justify their screentime.

Unfortunately, like The Sentinels before it, it ends at just about the point that the story seems to be kicking into gear. The creative team intended to follow this with a sequel, which has been teased to fans on various occasions. That sequel has persistently not materialized, in part to avoid stepping on the toes of the live action movie that was in development (which also never materialized, and that was probably just as well).

Now Robotech keeps sputtering out attempts at continuations every decade or so, and The Shadow Chronicles doesn't even represent the final release under its banner - so nothing's impossible. Still, I would be extremely surprised if any animated continuation of this story ever actually got released.

I was entertained enough that I might have given this a "7." But the lack of a proper ending, combined with the annoying conflicts with pre-existing continuity, knock that down to...


Overall Rating: 6/10.

Previous Movie: Robotech - The Sentinels
Next Movie: Love Live Alive

Review Index


To receive new review updates, follow me:

On BlueSky:

On Threads:

Tuesday, October 22, 2024

2-19. Crisis/Crisis Point.

Jeanne and her squadron attempt a desperate escape!
Jeanne and her squadron attempt a desperate escape!

Super Dimension Cavalry Southern Cross: Crisis.

Original Air Date - Super Dimension Cavalry Southern Cross: Sept. 2, 1984. Writer: Tadashi Terada. Director: Mikio Suzuki.

Robotech: Crisis Point.

Original Air Date - Robotech: May 20, 1985.
Story Editor: Steve Kramer. Supervising Director: Robert V. Barron.


PLOT - SOUTHERN CROSS

Jeanne and the 15th squadron are prisoners of the Zor - but not for long. After Seifriet leaves his designated area, the Zor decide that the humans are too dangerous to be allowed to live. When Musica discovers this, she stages a daring rescue.

With Musica's help, the squad is able to rescue Seifriet, whose memories have been restored. They make their way back to their mechs. But with the Zor locking down the entire ship, Jeanne isn't sure how she's going to get her squad away and back to the safety of Gloire!


PLOT - ROBOTECH:

Dana and the 15th squadron are prisoners of the Robotech Masters - but not for long. After Zor leaves his designated area, the Masters decide that the humans are too dangerous to be allowed to live. When Musica discovers this, she stages a daring rescue.

With Musica's help, the squad is able to rescue Zor, whose memories of his prior life have been restored. They make their way back to their mechs. But with the Masters locking down the entire ship, Dana isn't sure how she's going to get her squad away and back to the safety of Earth!

Musica and Bowie.
Musica helps the humans against her own people.

CHARACTERS:

There's a scene that really captures the difference in characterization between Southern Cross's Andrzej and Robotech's Angelo. Just after escaping confinement, the squad comes to the control center of the ship. Andrzej argues that they should forego rescuing Seifriet and instead complete their mission by destroying the control center. Robotech's Angelo wants the same thing, but changes in dialogue shift the emphasis. Andrzej wants to do his duty; Angelo seems to just want to blow stuff up for the sake of it. Because while Andrzej is a soldier dedicated to duty, Angelo is mostly just an imbecile.

This is a big episode for Musica. Her feelings for Bowie have overwhelmed her, and she tells her sisters that she wishes she could be alone sometimes instead of always with them. When she learns that Bowie and his squad are to be executed, she takes action - passing a point of no return with the Zor, though (at least in Southern Cross) she still wants to save her own people as well.

Advantage: Southern Cross.


NARRATION:

After the recap, Southern Cross has an establishing shot of the aftermath of the battle before the camera moves to the Zor ship. It's an effective opening visual for the viewer to absorb with no words needed... but since Robotech doesn't do silence, the narrator talks over it, telling us about how the wreckage is "a grim reminder of the horrors of war." Yeah, thanks for that, Mr. Narrator. Where would we be if you left us to interpret visuals for ourselves?

Advantage: Southern Cross.

Seifriet has flashes of memory. So does Zor in Robotech, but the meaning is very different.
Seifriet has flashes of memory. So does Zor
in Robotech, but the meaning is very different.

CUTS AND ALTERATION:

The Masters Talk About the Invid: While watching the humans bicker in their cell, the Zor leaders are bemused that they don't seem to realize their situation. In Robotech, the Masters talk about the Invid, discussing how their actions are saving the humans from the upcoming invasion just as much as they're saving themselves.

Zor's Memories Are of "the Protoculture Site": As Seifriet wanders in a daze, he sees flashes of memory from his time on Gloire, which Musica confirms when she finds him. In Robotech, Musica focuses on Zor remembering his visit to "the protoculture site" - the cave with the flowers - even though that scene is depicted in exactly none of these flashbacks.

Louis Explains the Plan in More Detail: The squad discovers Seifriet as his memories are being processed. Observing what's happening, Louis advises waiting until all his memories are restored before staging the rescue. This is the same in Robotech, except that Louis is far more detailed as he goes over the plan, to the point that I half-expected Spaceballs' Dark Helmet to appear and ask, "Everybody got that?"

The Alarm Becomes a Barrier Control: In Southern Cross, the control center features an alarm that can be sounded to alert the civilians to flee the ship. Robotech changes this to a "barrier control" that must be deactivated for Dana's squad to break free. This completely changes the context of Musica and Bowie running for that control. In Southern Cross, they want to save the Zor civilians; in Robotech, they're trying to make good their own escape.

Gen. Emerson's Orders: In Southern Cross, Emerson orders his forces to break off their attack in twenty more minutes. Robotech apparently decided this was too slack a deadline, tightening it to five minutes and making Dana's final escape a lot less likely than Jeanne's, which was pretty darn unlikely to start with!

Seifriet's Fate: When Seifriet announces that he'll delay the Zor and catch up, Andrzej clearly recognizes that he has no intention of doing so. As a result, while the others escape, Andrzej goes back to rescue him. Robotech's Angelo is way too dumb for that, so Zor now escapes on his own, and what had been Andrzej's mech is now explained away as Zor having brought "a change of clothes." Thus, a terrific character beat for Andrzej is tossed aside for no readily apparent reason.

Advantage: Southern Cross.


INCIDENTAL MUSIC:

It's fair to say that many of Robotech's tracks feel overused by this point. It's still good music, so it usually isn't a problem when it's well-applied. But it feels more overused than usual in this episode, a sense that isn't helped by Robotech stuffing every non-dialogue scene with wall-to-wall music. Southern Cross allows several scenes to play without incidentals, which helps to vary the tone and increases the impact of the scenes that do rely on music.

Advantage: Southern Cross.

Zor guards apprehend Seifriet.
Zor guards apprehend Seifriet. 

OVERALL ADVANTAGE - SOUTHERN CROSS:

Southern Cross's Andrzej receives some excellent character moments, while Robotech's Angelo mainly comes across as violent and dumb. Robotech also overexplains certain plot elements, while other changes appear to have been made for no reason at all. The episode remains entertaining either way, but I definitely prefer the original version.


OTHER MUSINGS:

Crisis finishes up what has effectively been a three-parter surrounding the infiltration, exploration, and escape from the Zor mothership. Wonderland was the high point, with the characters' exploration of the alien environment being more interesting than the combat-heavy episodes on either side. Still, Crisis remains an entertaining installment. It offers choice character moments for Seifriet, Andrzej, and Musica, with action that is generally well-animated and fun to watch.

Robotech suffers from weaker characterization (as usual) and a few bizarre changes. In Robotech, this is the weakest of the three episodes, while I'd rate the Southern Cross version about even with Bio Psychers.


Overall Rating - Southern Cross: 7/10.

Overall Rating - Robotech: 6/10.

Previous Episode: Wonderland/Dana in Wonderland
Next Episode: Daydream/Daydreamer

Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On BlueSky:

On Threads:

Tuesday, October 1, 2024

2-16. Hunter Killer/The Hunters.

Louis beams with pride when he's asked to modify an invention for training. He doesn't stay proud for long.
Louis beams with pride when he's asked to modify an
invention for training. He doesn't stay proud for long.

Super Dimension Cavalry Southern Cross: Hunter Killer.

Original Air Date - Super Dimension Cavalry Southern Cross: Aug. 5, 1984. Writer: Tomoko Kawasaki. Director: Mikio Suzuki.

Robotech: The Hunters.

Original Air Date - Robotech: May 15, 1985.
Story Editor: Steve Kramer. Supervising Director: Robert V. Barron.


PLOT - SOUTHERN CROSS

To reach Aluce Base, Gen. Emerson's forces must pass near the region of space occupies by the Zor. Emerson hopes to traverse this area without the Zor noticing, and he appears to get his wish - only to find the aliens preparing a trap near their lunar destination.

Meanwhile, Louis has invented a device that vastly improves his performance on a flight simulator game. This attracts the notice of two senior officers, who recruit him to modify his device for use in training simulations. But after completing his work, Louis learns that his invention will be used for more than just training...


PLOT - ROBOTECH:

To reach Moonbase Luna, Gen. Emerson's forces must pass near the edge of a nebula that is uncomfortably close to the Robotech Masters. Emerson hopes to traverse this area without the enemy noticing, and he appears to get his wish - only to find the aliens preparing a trap near their lunar destination.

Meanwhile, Louis has invented a device that vastly improves his performance on a flight simulator game. This attracts the notice of two senior officers, who recruit him to modify his device for use in training simulations. But after completing his work, Louis learns that his invention will be used for more than just training...

Gen. Emerson sweats during a tense moment while sneaking though Zor territory.
Emerson hopes to avoid battle by sneaking past the Zor.

CHARACTERS:

Gen. Emerson shows both prudence and strength as a commander. When the Zor appear not to notice the humans as they pass near their ships, a subordinate urges a surprise attack. Emerson rebuffs this, reminding the younger man that their mission is to reinforce the base. Unspoken but clear is that getting killed in space will make that mission a failure. However, when battle becomes unavoidable, Emerson doesn't hesitate to engage the enemy and is quick to come up with a solution to their dilemma.

At least, all of that is true in Southern Cross. Most of it is still true in Robotech. However, the Robotech episode tacks in some dialogue with a subordinate urging Emerson to action when the Robotech Masters attack, which makes the general look a lot less decisive.

The episode's other strand shines a spotlight on Louis. We already know that he likes to tinker. Here, he explains to Jeanne why he's so interested in machines, talking about how machines are able to offset man's inherent limitations. He dreams of inventing something that will enable humanity to reach its full potential, and Jeanne is impressed at his romantic ideals. It's a key scene, because it shows all the reasons why he's so appalled when he discovers the true purpose for which his invention is being deployed.

Advantage: Southern Cross.


NARRATION:

Southern Cross's opening narration is the usual recap, focusing on Gen. Emerson's mission to expand the human forces at Aluce Base and the Zor's plans to stop him. Robotech's narration shifts focus entirely, placing the emphasis on setting up the Invid Invasion for the third arc. It's an understandable change, but it does mean that relatively little groundwork is laid for those who might have missed the previous episode.

Advantage: Southern Cross.

Jeanne tests Louis's invention.
Jeanne tests Louis's invention.

CUTS AND ALTERATION:

The Nebula: To reach Aluce Base, Gen. Emerson's forces pass through a zone controlled by the Zor. Robotech slightly alters this by having them pass through the edge of a nebula to reach Moonbase Luna.

Added Technobabble: When Louis describes the way the game works in Southern Cross, what he says is technical but still basically straightforward. Robotech decides to go the full Star Trek, with Louis descending into a soup of Technobabble that I suspect is mostly gibberish.

The Odds of Breaking Through the Enemy: When the Zor spring their trap in Southern Cross, Gen. Emerson first tries to just break through without engaging. He asks what the odds are, and is told there's a 51% chance of success. Robotech's writers must have decided that wasn't dramatic enough, as the American show changes this to a 20% chance. This actually hurts Emerson's characterization. In Southern Cross, he has a basically even chance of getting his forces out of danger by just flying through, making it a sensible order to give. In Robotech, his odds are slim, making his order seem desperate.

Sean Has Suspicions: Both episodes come back from commercial to a scene in which Charles/Sean talks about Louis's game. Robotech changes the conversation slightly. Unlike Charles, Sean voices suspicions that Major Cromwell's plans for the device may go beyond a mere training simulation. I actually like this change. Combined with a slight change of emphasis when Cromwell first asked to use the device, it more strongly foreshadows the ending. It also fits with Sean's background, given that he was the 15th squadron's original commander before he was busted back to private; even in peacetime, he would have had some experience dealing with interdepartmental politics, and he'd know to be wary of others' motives.

Lt. Brown's Reasons for Joining the Mission: Lt. Brown announces that he'll be joining the 15th Squadron for the next phase of the Supreme Commander's plan. In Southern Cross, he wants to support Gen. Emerson. Robotech alters the dialogue so that he wants to prove his bravery to the general - which makes it sound less like personal loyalty and more as if he's angling for a promotion. I prefer the Southern Cross version.

Bad Dialogue Ruins a Major Reveal: Robotech continues its ongoing struggle with dialogue that sounds either juvenile or clunky or both. This is particularly noticeable in the dramatic reveal of how Louis's invention is being applied. The Southern Cross scene is quite strong, with effective moments for Jeanne, Louis, Bowie, Seifriet, and Andrzej. In Robotech, almost every line lands with a thud, ruining the episode's major scene.

Advantage: Southern Cross.


INCIDENTAL MUSIC:

This is an action-heavy episode, and Southern Cross's "battle music" isn't particularly impressive. That makes it little surprise that Robotech wins this category. Most noticeably, Robotech uses one of its tracks to very strong effect when Louis's game is demonstrated just before a cut back to the battle, musically connecting the two scenes more smoothly than the same transition in the original verison.

Advantage: Robotech.

Caught in a Zor trap, Gen. Emerson tries a desperate tactic.
Caught in a Zor trap, Gen. Emerson tries a desperate tactic.

OVERALL ADVANTAGE - SOUTHERN CROSS:

Robotech suffers from some of the clunkiest dialogue the show has delivered in a while, which really harms the episode's most emotional moment. Emerson's character is also made to look weaker, thanks to dialogue from his subordinates making it appear that he's hesitant instead of decisive.


OTHER MUSINGS:

The Southern Cross episode is quite good. The "A" and "B" plots have no immediate impact on each other, but both strands are well-presented and enjoyable. The episode also moves along at a pace that's fast without feeling rushed. The Southern Cross writers know to slow down for a good character scene between Jeanne and Louis, while also finding time to show Bowie worrying about his father (or godfather, in Robotech) while at the same time pretending not to worry.

The Robotech version remains watchable. The fast pace is built into this one, and the Robotech music benefits the action scenes. But the dialogue problems make Robotech noticeably worse in this instance, resulting in one of the weakest episodes of the Americanized show in a while.


Overall Rating - Southern Cross: 7/10.

Overall Rating - Robotech: 5/10.

Previous Episode: Love Story/Love Song
Next Episode: Bio Psycher/Mind Games

Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On BlueSky:

On Threads:

Tuesday, August 6, 2024

2-08. Metal Fire.

A study of a captured bioroid yields disturbing implications.
A study of a captured bioroid yields disturbing implications.

Original Air Date - Super Dimension Cavalry Southern Cross: June 10, 1984. Writer: Hisato Shimogochi. Director: Yoshihito Hata.

Original Air Date - Robotech: May 3, 1985.
Story Editor: Steve Kramer. Supervising Director: Robert V. Barron.


PLOT - SOUTHERN CROSS

The Zor bioroid pilot captured by Jeanne dies, but his mech yields insights into the enemy. The bioroid's technology is such that it responds directly to nerve impulses, allowing the pilots to fight in their mechs as easily and instinctively as if they were their own bodies.

Claude Leon, the supreme general, insists that the enemy are renegade humans who turned to space piracy and thus deserve no mercy. Jeanne is convinced that the pilots are actually humans who were captured by the Zor. The general refuses to even consider this, leaving a dejected Jeanne returning to her squad.

Then the Zor attack the city, specifically attempting to capture civilians. It's Jeanne's duty to fight back - but convinced that the enemy pilots are victims themselves, she finds herself unwilling to shoot to kill...


PLOT - ROBOTECH:

The pilot Dana captured dies, but his mech yields insights into the enemy. The fighter's technology is such that it responds directly to nerve impulses, allowing the pilots to fight in their mechs as easily and instinctively as if they were their own bodies.

Anatole Leonard, the supreme commander, insists that the enemy must be micronized Zentraedi - little more than androids in his view, deserving no mercy. Dana is certain the pilots are living beings. Anatole refuses to even consider this, leaving a dejected Dana returning to her squad.

Then the Masters' forces attack the city, specifically attempting to capture civilians. It's Dana's duty to fight back - but convinced that the enemy pilots are victims themselves, she finds herself unwilling to shoot to kill...

Jeanne wrestles with continuing to fight pilots who are victims themselves.
Jeanne wrestles with continuing to fight
pilots who are victims themselves.

CHARACTERS:

Tech-savvy Louis quickly figures out how the bioroid responds to human gestures. He also displays his analytical skills, bringing up data for those attacks against the enemy that were effective and in so doing, showing what attacks the enemy is most vulnerable to.

Jeanne's intelligence is more intuitive. Her instincts tell her that the pilots are not the alien clones they observed on the ship, but are instead captured humans. Unfortunately, since she can't back up her suspicions with hard data, she can't really articulate her point to command. Honestly, even if she had all the data in the world, I doubt Claude Leon would pay attention anyway.

Robotech remains effective at showing Louis's analytical abilities. Changes to the script, however, leave Dana's reactions a lot more muddled than Jeanne's, harming her characterization.

Advantage: Southern Cross.


NARRATION:

The Robotech episode opens with an extended recap of the previous episode. The narrator doesn't even pause for breath before pivoting to exposition, reminding us that the Masters have come to Earth for protoculture to keep their society from collapsing. Then, as we cut to Dana, he talks about Dana's internal conflict. But he's not done yet! When we cut to Musica aboard the Masters' ship, the narrator tells us about her (including her name), before expositing about the Masters some more when the action cuts to them.

Across the first six minutes of the episode, the narrator talks more than any of the characters do! It's pared back to a reasonable level after that, but it barely mattered. By the six-minute mark, I was actually laughing aloud at the incessant narration, and it overshadowed the rest of the Robotech version of the episode for me.

Advantage: Southern Cross

The alien Musica plays. In Robotech, she and her 'assistants' also hold a telepathic conversation.
The alien Musica plays. In Robotech, she and her
"assistants" also hold a telepathic conversation.

CUTS AND ALTERATION:

Dana Frets About Her Mixed Heritage: Robotech's Dana Sterling is the daughter of Miriya, a Zentraedi, so she frets about continuing to fight aliens who might be related to her. The source of hesitation for Southern Cross's Jeanne is her intuitive certainty that the enemy pilots are humans and not aliens at all.

Musica and Her Function: In Southern Cross, the alien woman Bowie met in the last episode plays silently. Then two other young women, identical to her, enter, and she stops playing until they gesture for her to continue. All of this is wordless. In Robotech, the narrator informs us that Musica (the woman) plays for functional reasons, and that the two others are her assistants. Also, because Robotech remains utterly terrified of silence, they speak telepathically through the whole scene.

The Zor Worry About Their Noncombatants; the Masters Don't: In the first scene with the alien leaders, Southern Cross has them worrying about the noncombatants on their ship and expressing frustration at the humans' continued attacks. The Robotech Masters don't even mention the civilians.

The Masters Discuss the Invid: The Robotech Masters talk about how they've come to Earth for the protoculture before the real threat to both them and the humans arrives: The Invid. Thus, the writers begin setting up the third generation.

Acting Commander Andrzej: In both versions, Andrzej/Angelo is made acting commander of the squad while Jeanne/Dana attends the briefing. Southern Cross has an early scene in which Andrzej relieves the previous patrol. Charles attempts to sneak into a coffee house during the patrol, only to be stopped by Andrzej. Robotech moves the first part of the scene to the second half, combining it with Dana's return to the squad. The coffee shop bit is removed entirely.

Jeanne vs. Dana in Protesting the Supreme Commander: Jeanne at least tries to make a case when she argues, pointing out that she and her squad observed alien clones while on the ship. Dana merely protests that the pilots are "living beings" (which, last I checked, wouldn't actually contradict them being Zentraedi) before declaring Anatole to be a fool if he doesn't listen to her. I'm frankly a bit surprised she doesn't end up back in the brig for insubordination.

The Masters Use Added Technobabble: Both Southern Cross's Zor and the Robotech Masters make the same basic plan to deal with the humans: kidnap them and use the captives as bioroid pilots. Southern Cross keeps that simple and straightforward. Robotech inserts a bunch of extra technobabble, with the Masters planning to first subject their captives to "a xzylonic mental probe." No, not the mind probe!

Claude Blames Gen. Emerson for the Attack; Anatole Justifies His Decisions: The tag is completely different despite the same animations. In Southern Cross, Claude blames Emerson's "indecisiveness" for the attack even happening. In Robotech, Emerson is the one blaming Anatole, snapping that "negotiating couldn't have been worse than this." In interests of fairness, I think one Robotech addition to this scene is actually an improvement, with Anatole instructing that the kidnapped civilians be listed not as missing, but as casualties.

Advantage: Southern Cross.


INCIDENTAL MUSIC:

While each version uses its score well, I think Southern Cross is more effective overall. I will admit that I might be suffering a bit of fatigue from Robotech's music by this point, though: After 45 episodes, I can predict with relative accuracy which track will drop at which moment.

Advantage: Southern Cross.

The Zor attack the city in search of new bioroid pilots.
The Zor attack the city in search of new bioroid pilots.

OVERALL ADVANTAGE - SOUTHERN CROSS:

The Robotech Masters come across as more desperate than the Zor, stuck in a course of action simply because they have no other hope for survival. This is an aspect of the Robotech version that I quite like. I also liked the addition of Anatole ordering the kidnapped citizens to be reported as casualties.

However, other changes are decidedly for the worse. Robotech attempts to make use of the Zentraedi backstory from The Macross Saga, but the continuity doesn't line up. The previous generation's epilogue arc indicated that a substantial minority of the aliens joined Khyron's rebellion, but most of them preferred to integrate with the humans. It would be simplicity itself to make a few side characters Zentraedi. Instead, every reference indicates that the Zentraedi were all enemies and they were all defeated.

That has already been annoying me. But this episode is even worse, suddenly indicating that the Zentraedi are androids. What? Dana, our main character, is half-Zentraedi; I somehow doubt she thinks of her mother as an android. Heck, her first scene in this episode has her hesitation to fight based on fear of potentially killing someone she's related to - so the Robotech script isn't even consistent within this one episode!

Combined with the ludicrous amount of narration in the first six minutes, this leaves me judging the Robotech version as not only worse than the original, but considerably worse.

Inside the Zor ship. I really like the visual design here.
Inside the Zor ship. I really like the visual design here.

OTHER MUSINGS:

Metal Fire provides a lot of exposition about the Zor. We learn how their bioroids work, and why they are able to operate their mechs so much more fluidly than the humans. Southern Cross also indicates that the pilots are captured humans, which presumably explains all the missing personnel from the moon attack. Finally, we get confirmation that the Zor do not view themselves as the aggressors in this conflict. This lines up well with the early episodes, in which every engagement was initiated by the humans.

In Southern Cross, this information is delivered efficiently, with the different threads working together: Jeanne grows increasingly certain that the pilots are human even as the Zor decide that their only way forward is to capture more humans. Jeanne's dilemma is effective: She doesn't want to kill humans who are themselves victims of their true enemy.

It's more muddled in Robotech. Dana is worried that she might be fighting relatives if their enemies are Zentraedi. But she's sure that the enemies aren't Zentraedi because they are living beings... which, somehow, no longer includes Zentraedi.

The final battle sees Jeanne making her first truly bad battlefield decisions. This make sense, because we understand why she's holding back. It doesn't work nearly as well in Robotech. When Angelo snarks that it doesn't matter who the pilots are, given that they're shooting at them, I don't get the impression that I'm supposed to be agreeing with him!

Usually, even with Robotech's ongoing issues with clunky dialogue, a good episode of the original show will mean a good episode of the American version. In this case, however, a pretty good Southern Cross is transformed into a mediocre - and somewhat frustrating - Robotech.


Overall Rating - Southern Cross: 7/10.

Overall Rating - Robotech: 5/10.

Previous Episode: Labyrinth Opera House/The Trap
Next Episode: Stardust

Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On BlueSky:

On Threads:

Tuesday, July 9, 2024

2-05. Trouble City/Danger Zone.

Jeanne sets her sights on a new dress. A major military operation ensues.
Jeanne wants a new dress. A major military operation ensues.

Super Dimension Cavalry Southern Cross - Trouble City.

Original Air Date - Super Dimension Cavalry Southern Cross: May 13, 1984. Writer: Jinzô Toriumi. Director: Susumu Nagao.

Robotech - Danger Zone

Original Air Date - Robotech: Apr. 30, 1985.
Story Editor: Steve Kramer. Supervising Director: Robert V. Barron.


PLOT - SOUTHERN CROSS

The Zor mothership continues to hover overhead. Claude Leon, the supreme general of the Southern Cross, orders an attack over Gen. Emerson's objections - an attack that results in devastating losses to the colony, with no damage done to the Zor.

This provides Jeanne with an opportunity. She wants to buy a very specific expensive dress, not least because both Marie and Lana also want it. There's one problem: Jeanne is broke. She'll need to distinguish herself to be able to draw the needed advance on her salary.

Fortunately, Louis Ducasse - one of her subordinates - is an engineering genius. Louis has a theory that the alien ship's drive system might be vulnerable to a targeted attack, provided an assault unit can get in close. The scientists agree, and with a bit of persuasion from Jeanne, Gen. Emerson allows her to lead a second, targeted attack: For the honor of her squad, for the security of Gloire, and - most importantly - for the right to buy that dress and rub Marie's and Lana's noses in it!


PLOT - ROBOTECH:

The Robotech Masters' mothership continues to hover overhead. Anatole Leonard, the supreme commander of the Army of the Southern Cross, orders an attack over Gen. Emerson's objections - an attack that results in devastating losses to the colony, with no damage done to the enemy.

Fortunately, Louis - one of Dana Sterling's subordinates - is an engineering genius. Louis has a theory that the alien ship's drive system might be vulnerable to a targeted attack, provided an assault unit can get in close. The scientists agree, and with a bit of persuasion from Dana, Gen. Emerson allows her to lead a second, targeted attack!

Claude Leon, supreme general of the Southern Cross, looks like Lex Luthor and has the personality to match.
Claude Leon, supreme general of the Southern Cross,
looks like Lex Luthor and has the personality to match.

CHARACTERS:

This episode continues the ongoing difference in characterization between Jeanne and Dana. Carefree, frivolous Jeanne is motivated to perform a heroic action so that she can buy a dress - specifically, a dress that she had rejected until Marie and Lana wanted it. By contrast, Dana acts solely out of sense of duty.

We get some focus on Louis, who has thus far been "present" but hasn't actually done much. Here, we learn that he's a bit of a tech genius... something that probably should have been introduced before this point, as it feels awfully convenient that he just happens to have this extraordinary knowledge base at the exact moment that it's needed.

Trouble City also introduces Claude Leon, Gen. Emerson's superior. He looks like Lex Luthor and has the personality to match, only minus the brains. He's written as less directly antagonistic in Robotech, though he's still the commander who forces a disastrously bad call in either version.

Advantage: None.


NARRATION:

Once the Robotech episode gets past its extended recap, the remaining narration is fairly restrained. As a result, the bulk of the voice over is restricted to the equivalent of a "Previously on..." segment.

Advantage: None

Marie and Lana make faces at the camera. Robotech removes their motivation, making an already bad moment incoherent.
Marie and Lana make faces at the camera. Robotech removes
their motivation, making an already bad moment incoherent.

CUTS AND ALTERATION:

Robotech Opens with a Recap: The Robotech episode spends almost two minutes summarizing the events of the previous episode, even though those events are only briefly mentioned here. I think this can safely be put down to padding the runtime to make up for one big cut...

Jeanne, Marie, and Lana Shop for a Dress - but Only in Southern Cross. This three-minute scene sets up Jeanne's personal quest, as she shops for and rejects a dress - only to decide that she must have it after Marie and Lana express interest in it. I agree with this cut; all of this works with Southern Cross's Jeanne, but not so much for Robotech's Dana's. My only complaint is that Robotech should have also cut the ending scene, as it's a callback to a subplot that's been otherwise removed.

Anatole Leonard Is Conciliatory to Emerson: Southern Cross's Claude Leon is scornful of Emerson. He pushes for the ill-fated offensive, then denounces its inevitable failure as pitiful before stalking out. Robotech's Anatole half-apologizes to Emerson for overruling him, stating the assault "was the only way." When it goes spectacularly wrong, he seems suitably shocked.

Scientists Confirm the Enemy Are Not Miniaturized Zentraedi: Both episodes feature a scene with scientists studying an alien bioroid. In Southern Cross, the main finding is that the fighter is controlled by a human pilot; in Robotech, the report confirms that the pilot is not a miniaturized Zentraedi. Given that "The Macross Saga" told us that the Zentraedi were genetically identical to humans, I'm not sure how they determine this. That aside, it's a good choice to use the "Macross Saga" backstory; after the Zentraedi, it would seem strange for the humans to be shocked at the existence of human-looking aliens.

A Lot More Technobabble: The Southern Cross episode establishes that the alien ship uses a particle reactor to move, and that it can be disabled by disturbing the ship's balance - and it's expressed as straightforwardly as that. The Robotech episode inserts extra Technobabble about space folding and simultaneous implosions and explosions. Given that it ends up with the same result, I'm not sure why.

Bowie's Relationship to Emerson: As the last episode revealed, Southern Cross's Emerson is Bowie's father. Robotech changes this so that Emerson is a friend of Bowie's father who agreed to look out for the young man... which basically makes their relationship the same, only less direct. Why? The most likely response is that it was the '80s and they didn't want a mixed-race father-and-son, but... Well, the show had already featured an interracial romance in "The Macross Saga," with Claudia and Roy, and that didn't stop Robotech from being a hit, so I have no clue why this was changed.

Dana Does Not Tear Her New Dress: Jeanne buys the dress, much to the annoyance of Marie and Lana. As she gets onto her bike, she catches the hem on a fire hydrant and rips it as she zips away, prompting Marie and Lana to laugh and make faces at the camera. I already find this bad, even borderline embarrassing. Robotech manages to make a terrible scene even worse by making only one change: unlike Jeanne, Dana doesn't tear her dress. As a result, there's no reason for Marie and Nova's reaction. It's a lame and unfunny gag either way... but at least the Southern Cross version is coherent.

Advantage: Southern Cross.

Robotech's music makes the big action climax feel rushed.
Robotech's music makes the big action climax feel rushed.

INCIDENTAL MUSIC:

The big action climax provides another look at the impact of music on a scene, but this time it's not in Robotech's favor. As usual, Robotech has left the action set piece untouched. However, the music is changed to a succession of almost all of Robotech's action tracks, one after another. Rather than energizing the scene, as has been the case in some previous episodes, this time it utterly ruins it.

Southern Cross allows several moments to play with either subdued music that most viewers won't consciously register or with no music at all. Robotech, afraid of silence as always, never lets the music stop. Southern Cross brings in music to emphasize moments of tension. Robotech just lines up a series of fast-paced tracks. This destroys any emphasis on one moment over another.

Even worse, that succession of fast tempo music makes the action feel rushed. I actually went back and checked the timing of the sequence in both versions afterward. There's no real difference... but while it plays cleanly and easy-to-follow in Southern Cross, it feels like an almost senseless jumble of activity in Robotech. And the reason why is all down to the music.

Advantage: Southern Cross

Human scientists study the Zor bioroid.
Human scientists study the Zor bioroid.

OVERALL ADVANTAGE - SOUTHERN CROSS:

The Southern Cross version is better than Robotech for two main reasons: The light-hearted early scenes in town, which have been greatly reduced in Robotech, create a contrast with the more serious tone of the rest of the episode; and, more importantly, the climactic action piece works in Southern Cross and falls badly flat in Robotech.


OTHER MUSINGS:

I'll start with the good elements. The introduction of Claude Leon/Anatole Leonard will almost certainly create plot complications moving forward, and the show is at the point where it needs something more than "brave squad of misfits battles formidable aliens" to maintain interest. The episode moves quickly. It also does the best job yet of juggling the ensemble, finding good moments for not only Jeanne, but also Louis, Charles, Andrzej, and Bowie. It's generally watchable, even if it isn't good.

That aside, this episode is extremely dumb. How do Jeanne and her squadron break through the Zor defenses in the first place? These same defenses effortlessly wiped out the forces sent by Emerson and Leon, none of which came close to even scratching the paint of the alien ship! A better script might show the squad analyzing the data from the battle and discovering a gap that a small force can exploit... but no. They get through simply because, unlike the nameless pilots in the first half, they have Plot Armor!

Also, the battle is much too easy. Jeanne's squad is literally on enemy territory. This should be a grueling fight to reach the Death Star vent... er, drive system. Nope. They blast a few bioroids as they all but stroll to the Designated Weak Spot in order to Blow It Up Real Good. Given that the vulnerability has to do with throwing the ship off balance, it can be said that the Zor literally roll over and die for Jeanne and her squad.

I labeled the previous episode the best one so far in Southern Cross. Well, this one earns the opposite, less desirable title, as easily my least favorite Southern Cross episode so far - and impressively, the Robotech version is even worse!


Overall Rating - Southern Cross: 4/10.

Overall Rating - Robotech: 3/10.

Previous Episode: Half Moon
Next Episode: Prelude/Prelude to Battle

Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On BlueSky:

On Threads: