Stig shares a happy moment with his fiancée on the eve of battle. |
Genesis Climber Mospeada: Prelude to the Offensive.
Original Air Date - Genesis Climber Mospeada: Oct. 2, 1983. Writer: Sukehiro Tomita. Director: Tatsuya Kasahara, Katsuhisa Yamada.
Robotech: The Invid Invasion.
Original Air Date - Robotech: May 27, 1985.
Story Editor: Steve Kramer. Supervising Director: Robert V. Barron.
PLOT - MOSPEADA:
In the year 2050, an alien race known as the Inbit invaded Earth. Those humans who were able to escape fled, while the rest were left to live under their new alien masters. Attempts to reclaim Earth failed, and a generation of humans grew up knowing only the colony base on Mars as home.
More than thirty years after the initial invasion, the Mars Expeditionary Force is certain that they've learned from past failures. A new offensive launches to stop the Inbit, targeting the aliens' headquarters at Reflex Point in North America. The captain advises all pilots that in the event they are shot down but make it to Earth, they should converge on Reflex Point to complete the mission.
One of these pilots is Stig Bernard, who has just become engaged to Marlene, a bridge officer on the carrier leading the assault. The Inbit defenses are more formidable than expected, but Stig and his comrades are able to fight them off. During the final approach to Earth, however, the humans discover that something has happened to the atmosphere that makes it hotter than their shielding is designed for. Stig is able to compensate - but the large carrier cannot, nor is it able to pull out. Stig is left to watch helplessly as the ship, with Marlene aboard, is destroyed.
Now Stig is alone. He has no backup and no expectation of finding other survivors. His fighter is no longer usable, leaving him only with his Mospeada, a small motorcycle mech carried inside the fighter. He remains determined to reach Reflex Point to finish the mission - not only for Earth, but for the sake of his own vengeance!
PLOT - ROBOTECH:
In 2031, the Invid come to Earth, drawn by the call of the Flower of Life. The Army of the Southern Cross, depleted and exhausted by its war with the Robotech Masters, is unable to repel these new invaders, and Earth quickly falls.
Admiral Rick Hunter sends a contingent of ships to reclaim the Earth. They arrive in 2042, more than a decade after the invasion. Their target is Reflex Point in North America, which has become the headquarters of the Regess, the Invid queen.
Scott Bernard, a pilot attached to this mission, has just proposed to his girlfriend, bridge officer Marlene, when the attack begins. The Invid defenses prove more formidable than expected, and Scott and his comrades are barely able to fight back the first wave. In desperation to land before a second wave begins, the captain of the lead carrier enters Earth's atmosphere too quickly. Scott is left to watch helplessly as the ship, with Marlene aboard, is destroyed.
Now Scott is all alone. He has no backup and no expectations of finding other survivors. His fighter is no longer usable, leaving him only with his emergency vehicle, a small motorcycle mech carried inside the fighter. He remains determined to reach Reflex Point to finish the mission - not only for Earth, but for the sake of his own vengeance!
Stig finds a message inside Marlene's final gift to him. |
CHARACTERS:
There's no two ways about this: Scott is a better name for the main character than Stig. This may be a case of "lost in translation," but to this American viewer, "Stig" sounds like the name you'd give to a comedy sidekick with an annoyingly high-pitched voice, not to the square-jawed hero of the piece.
There's no real difference in characterization, but I think Robotech does the better job of establishing a connection between Scott and the viewer. This is mainly due to something that's usually one of the American show's more annoying tendencies: internal voice-overs. When Scott crashes in a forest, he quickly decides that he doesn't much like Earth, observing how easy it would be for an enemy to hide among the trees. This feels correct for the character as presented, and it brings us closer to his point-of-view in a way that just isn't true in Mospeada.
Advantage: Robotech.
NARRATION:
Mospeada opens with some narration that quickly sketches in the backstory, with the main body of the episode playing out with no voice-over. Robotech changes the backstory to fit the overall narrative, with the Invid having been called by Zor's misguided final act and with the attempt to reclaim Earth coming from Admiral Rick Hunter's fleet. The narrator mostly stays out of the way for the rest of the episode, but internal monologues for Scott help to characterize him better than Mospeada's Stig. These end up tipping the advantage in this category to Robotech.
Advantage: Robotech.
Ray flees from the Inbit. Robotech adds a lot of quipping. |
CUTS AND ALTERATION:
The Attack Comes from Admiral Hunter: In Mospeada, the humans who fled Earth settled on Mars and have made previous unsuccessful attempts to drive the Inbit away. Robotech changes this substantially. The attack is the first attempt to fight against the Invid since the initial invasion, and the attackers come from Admiral Rick Hunter's fleet so that Macross characters can be name-dropped... because this is the same show, honest!
"Arty" Intercutting is Smoothed Out: When Stig and Marlene are introduced, Mospeada does a jarring, would-be arty cut from the fleet to Stig reaching for Marlene and back to the fleet again, only then finally cutting back to the rest of the scene. Robotech gets rid of the cutaway, leaving the characters' introduction to play out much more smoothly.
The Briefing: The ship's captain briefs Stig on the assignment, ordering that in the event of an emergency landing, Stig should make his way to Reflex Point. Robotech redubs this so that the captain is basically recapping what the narrator already has: That the Invid invaded Earth for its protoculture.
Marlene's Gift: Both versions have Marlene giving Stig/Scott a necklace with a message inside. In Mospeada, Marlene explicitly accepts Stig's marriage proposal while giving this gift, something the other crew members rib her about. In Robotech, this is removed so that Scott only realizes that his proposal was accepted when he later watches the message, after he's already lost her.
The Captain Enters Earth Atmosphere Too Quickly: The carrier is destroyed in Earth's atmosphere. In Mospeada, everything is going to plan, but the Inbit have somehow changed the atmosphere so that the heat is beyond the ship's tolerance. Robotech changes this so that it's the captain's fault, with him entering the atmosphere too quickly out of fear of another Invid wave. I have no idea why this was done, as it makes an otherwise competent officer suddenly seem like a panicked idiot while actually reducing the Invid's responsibility for the deaths of Marlene and Scott's shipmates.
The Captain's Orders: After surviving his first night on Earth, Stig recalls the captain's orders from the briefing scene. But since the captain didn't give those orders in Robotech, Scott instead has an audio-only flashback to a conversation we didn't witness, in which the captain gave basically the same orders. It's neither the first nor worst example in Robotech of a small change resulting in a more slapdash one, but it's worth mentioning.
Rand's Introduction is Intercut with Scott: In Mospeada, we cut from Stig riding into the desert to Ray's introductory scene, and we stay with Ray until Stig reaches him. Robotech snips away a bit of Rand's introduction, then cuts away from Rand back to Scott, I suspect to cover the additional trims made to the scene.
Rand Is Much Quippier Than Ray: When Mospeada's Ray flees the Inbit, he tries to shout back that he's not military, hoping that they'll break off the pursuit. Robotech's Rand instead makes a string of quips about how he's going to call his lawyer and sue for damages after they destroy his bike. Then he runs into Scott, who is similarly quippy (which doesn't even remotely fit his dour character) as he dispatches the aliens. It's one of the few scenes that I think works much better in the original version.
Advantage: Robotech. Though not every change is for the better, the overall episode is improved.
INCIDENTAL MUSIC:
This first episode just isn't enough for me to develop any kind of feel for Mospeada's score yet. There's nothing wrong with the way it's applied, but there also isn't any moment in which the music either stands out or is used in a subtle but effective way. The same is true for Robotech, which applies its usual cues in the usual way... but it does it well. The Robotech theme is trotted out when Scott transforms his Mospeada to battle some Invid. Unlike in other episodes where this theme has been a distraction, this is an appropriate use of "heroic" music, so the moment works.
Advantage: None.
Stig and Ray, alone in the wasteland. |
OVERALL ADVANTAGE - ROBOTECH:
Though I don't like the quipping that Robotech adds to the end battle, I'm still giving that version the advantage. It mainly comes down to the lead character. Those couple of internal voice overs help Scott to feel more relatable than Mospeada's Stig. I fully expect Mospeada to improve on this in future episodes - but Robotech does the better job of immediately connecting me to its new protagonist.
OTHER MUSINGS:
I can't claim to have had too strong a reaction to this episode in either version. It's a serviceable opener that establishes its lead and sets up the broad strokes of the story.
The art is generally good. I don't like the character art as well as in Macross, but I like it better than the character art for Southern Cross. The action sequences are well animated, and the Inbit designs do a good job of suggesting something alien while still being easily comprehensible.
Ultimately, that's about it for my initial response. The episode does everything that it needs to do. It's... fine. But particularly in its original version, I can't claim to thinking that it's anything more than that.
Overall Rating - Mospeada: 6/10.
Overall Rating - Robotech: 7/10.
Previous Episode: Genesis/Catastrophe
Next Episode: The Broken-Hearted Girl's March/The Lost City (not yet reviewed)
Review Index
To receive new review updates, follow me:
On Twitter:
On Threads: